Hot Bench Season 1 Episode 68 Schnauzer Puppy Snafu!; Clean and Sober ... and Married!

In the first case of Hot Bench Season 1 Episode 68, titled "Schnauzer Puppy Snafu!," two parties dispute over the purchase of a purebred Schnauzer puppy. The plaintiff claims that the defendant listed the puppy for sale online, and they agreed to purchase the dog for $1,200. However, upon bringing the puppy home, the plaintiff discovered that the dog was not a purebred Schnauzer, but rather a crossbred with several health issues. The plaintiff seeks a full refund for the puppy and additional damages for the costs associated with its health issues. The defendant argues that they never claimed the dog was a purebred Schnauzer and that the plaintiff should have done their due diligence before making the purchase.

The judges hear both sides of the argument and question the parties' sources of information regarding the dog's breed and health issues. One judge notes that the defendant's listing did not specify the puppy's breed, and both parties admit to not seeking professional veterinary advice before agreeing to the sale. As a result, the judges consider the possibility of shared fault and question whether the plaintiff is entitled to a full refund. Ultimately, the judges rule in favor of the plaintiff but award them only 50% of the original purchase price, citing the lack of clear communication and due diligence on both parties' parts.

In the second case of the episode, titled "Clean and Sober ... and Married!," a couple's dispute centers on the legality of their marriage and the distribution of assets following a divorce. The plaintiff argues that the marriage was not legally binding because they obtained their marriage license while under the influence of drugs and alcohol and did not proceed with a formal ceremony. The defendant counterclaims that the marriage was valid and seeks a fair distribution of assets, including a house and a retirement account.

To make their case, both parties testify about their relationship and the events leading up to their marriage. The plaintiff presents evidence of drug and alcohol abuse and alleges that the defendant coerced them into obtaining the marriage license without their full consent. The defendant argues that they were both sober at the time and had discussed marriage beforehand. The judges question both parties' credibility and attempt to discern the true nature of their relationship.

In the end, the judges rule that the marriage was indeed valid, as the couple obtained a marriage license and held themselves out as married to the public. However, they also acknowledge the plaintiff's allegations of abuse and award them a larger share of the marital assets, including the house and a portion of the retirement account. The judges commend the plaintiff for seeking help and moving forward with their life in a positive manner.

Overall, Hot Bench Season 1 Episode 68 offers two unique cases that showcase the judges' abilities to navigate complex legal issues and make fair and just decisions. The episode highlights the importance of clear communication, due diligence, and credibility in legal disputes and serves as a reminder that the law is not always black and white.