American Justice Season 30 Episode 11 In the Company of A Killer (#2111)

In the Company of A Killer is the eleventh episode of the thirtieth season of American Justice. This true-crime show takes a deep dive into the investigation and trial of Richard Beasley, a man who lured men to a secluded Ohio farm with the promise of work, only to rob and kill them.

The episode starts by introducing us to Richard Beasley, a conman who had spent time in prison before concocting his twisted scheme. He placed job listings on Craigslist, claiming to be a farmer in need of hired hands. When unemployed and desperate men arrived at the farm, Beasley would rob them at gunpoint and kill them.

The first half of the episode focuses on the disappearance of David Pauley, one of Beasley's victims. Pauley had posted an ad on Craigslist, looking for work to support his family. He arrived at the farm, but never returned home. His sister reported him missing, and the police searched for any clues. Beasley had taken Pauley's identification and phone, making it difficult for the authorities to track him down.

The story then takes a twist when Scott Davis, a young man from South Carolina, responds to one of Beasley's ads. He travels to Ohio and meets Beasley, who takes him to the secluded farm. But something seems off to Davis, and he becomes increasingly uncomfortable. He makes a run for it and is shot in the arm as he flees. Davis survives and later helps the police identify Beasley as the shooter.

The second half of the episode focuses on the investigation and trial of Beasley. The police uncovered several bodies on the farm, and Beasley slowly confesses to his crimes. His accomplice, Brogan Rafferty, is also arrested. Rafferty was a teenager at the time of the murders, and Beasley had manipulated him into helping with the crimes.

The trial is a complex one, with Beasley representing himself and often feuding with the judge. It took place over several years and was closely followed by the media. The episode delves into the legal arguments, witness testimonies, and evidence presented in the courtroom.

The final moments of the episode reveal the fate of Beasley and Rafferty. Without giving away any spoilers, it's clear that justice was served, but the emotional toll on the families of the victims is explored in depth.

Overall, In the Company of A Killer is a gripping episode that showcases the dangers of online scams and the tragic consequences that can come from trusting the wrong people. The storytelling, interviews, and reenactments are all well done, making it a must-watch for true-crime fans.