The People's Court Season 21 Episode 117 Music Mayhem
- May 1, 2018
The People's Court is back with season 21, episode 117 titled "Music Mayhem". The episode begins with two parties, both claiming to be rightful owners of a popular hit song. One party which is a group of three producers happens to have produced a song that sounds very similar to an old song which was copyrighted by another party. The producers are claiming that they had no idea about the previous copyright, and that the similarities were purely coincidental.
The plaintiff, on the other hand, claims that the defendants not only copied the melody from their copyrighted song, but also used their lyrics. Moreover, the plaintiff stated that the defendants had stolen their copyrighted work and had made a huge profit out of it, which was rightfully theirs.
Judge Milian, responsible for overseeing the case, patiently listened to both sides of the argument. Assessing the arguments, she ordered the defendants to play the song to give her a chance to listen to the similarities. The song which was played in court impressed the audience while enforcing the fact that there were indeed resemblances with the old copyrighted song.
To further inspect the similarities, the judge ordered a professional DJ and music producer to compare both songs. The comparison proved that the defendants had indeed copied the song from the plaintiffs without proper permission, violating copyright laws.
As the case progressed, the defendants made a case that they had not acquired any financial gain from this copyrighted work. The plaintiff, on the other hand, claimed that the defendants had sold the song to a famous musician, earning quite a significant amount of money from it.
To eliminate any further doubts and bring the case to a conclusive end, the Judge Milian considered multiple factors that play a role in such a decision. She reviewed the copyright agreement that the plaintiff had signed with the copyright office and noted any past precedents that dealt with copyright infringement cases.
After critically analyzing the facts, the judge finally gave her verdict. The defendants were found guilty of violating copyright laws and were ordered to pay the plaintiff a significant amount of money. The defendants were directed to stop producing and selling the song unless they receive proper authorization and permission from the plaintiff.
The episode concludes with the producers leaving the courtroom, trying to comprehend the verdict and the consequences that follow. The case offered a valuable lesson on the severity of copyright laws, emphasizing artists and producers to follow the law and respect the intellectual property rights of others.
Overall "Music Mayhem" was an interesting episode of The People's Court, showcasing the consequences that follow copyright violation cases, pointing out the importance of following copyright laws for all producers, artists, and creators.