Ep 120. Give me a puppy or else

The People's Court is a long-running American daytime television court show where real-life cases are decided by Judge Marilyn Milian. In season 23 episode 120 titled "Give me a puppy or else," viewers are presented with the case of a dispute between two ex-friends, Marcy and Nicole, who were once roommates. The issue at hand is a small, adorable puppy named Max who Marcy claims is rightfully hers, while Nicole insists that Max belongs to her.

Marcy tells Judge Milian that she had initially found the dog online and then drove for hours to pick him up from the breeder. She claims that her ex-roommate Nicole was initially excited about the new puppy and even helped her choose the name Max. However, tensions soon arose between the two friends, and they eventually had a falling out that led to Marcy moving out. According to Marcy, she left some of her belongings behind, including Max, who she intended to pick up later. When she returned a few days later, Max was gone, and Nicole refused to tell her where he was.

Nicole, on the other hand, tells the court that Marcy had abandoned Max and left him in her care. She alleges that Marcy had neglected the dog, leaving him alone in their apartment for hours on end, and that she was concerned for Max's well-being. She goes on to say that when Marcy left the apartment, she took all of her belongings with her, including Max's food and toys. According to Nicole, she had spoken to Marcy several times after the incident, informing her that Max was safe and happy and that she would not be giving him back.

The case is not as clear-cut as it first appears, and Judge Milian has to weigh both sides of the story carefully. She considers Marcy's argument that she had paid for Max and had never given up ownership of him. She also takes into account Nicole's claims that Marcy had abandoned the dog and that she was currently providing him with a loving home.

As the case proceeds, Judge Milian is presented with evidence from both sides, including photographs, text messages, and Facebook posts. Marcy produces a record of her payment to the breeder, which shows that she had indeed paid for the dog. She also presents photographs of Max when he was in her care, showing that she had taken good care of him.

Nicole, meanwhile, presents messages in which Marcy appears to have abandoned Max and expresses relief that he is in good hands. She also produces photographs of Max in her care, demonstrating that he is happy and well-fed.

Ultimately, Judge Milian decides that Marcy is the rightful owner of Max, as she had paid for him and never relinquished ownership. She orders Nicole to return the dog to Marcy and warns her not to interfere with Marcy's attempts to take Max home. The case is resolved, and Marcy leaves the courtroom with Max, overjoyed to have her beloved pet back in her life.

Overall, the episode is an engaging and emotional look at the often complex issues that arise when pets are involved in disputes between humans. The show does an excellent job of presenting both sides of the argument and allowing the audience to weigh up the evidence before coming to a decision. Judge Milian is a sympathetic yet authoritative presence in the courtroom, guiding the proceedings with a firm hand while never losing sight of the human element of the case. Fans of courtroom dramas and animal lovers alike will find much to enjoy in "Give me a puppy or else."