Ep 24. Rear Window / The Peeper

In Cold Case Files season 4 episode 24, titled Rear Window / The Peeper, viewers are introduced to a two-part episode that tells the story of two separate murders that took place years apart in the same quiet neighborhood.

The first murder, known as the Rear Window case, occurred in 1985 when a young woman named Vicky Thompson was found dead in her apartment. She had been strangled with a wire hanger and her body was left on her bed, posed in a sexually suggestive manner. At the time, police had no leads and the case went cold.

The second murder, known as The Peeper case, took place in the same neighborhood almost a decade later. In 1994, an elderly woman named Agnes Davidson was found dead in her home, also strangled. This case too went unsolved for years.

Years later, both cases are reopened by the cold case unit, which begins to investigate them as potential connected murders. The detectives begin by examining evidence from both cases and find some striking similarities.

In the Rear Window case, the detectives find evidence of a peeping tom who had been stalking Vicky in the days leading up to her murder. They also learn that several neighbors had reported seeing a man in a van parked outside her apartment building around the time of her death.

In the Peeper case, meanwhile, the detectives find evidence of a man who had been seen lurking outside Agnes' house in the weeks leading up to her death. Witnesses describe him as being in his 30s or 40s, with dark hair and a mustache, driving a white van.

With these leads in hand, the detectives begin to investigate potential suspects. They interview several men who match the descriptions given by witnesses, but none of them seem to fit the bill. Finally, they get a break when they are able to link a set of fingerprints found at the scene of Vicky's murder to a man named Gary.

Gary is a known sex offender who had been living in the neighborhood at the time of both murders. When questioned, he claims to have no knowledge of either crime. But as detectives dig deeper, they uncover a web of lies and deceit that could finally bring justice to the families of the victims.

As the two-part episode unfolds, viewers are taken on a thrilling ride through the twists and turns of the investigation. With detailed reenactments and interviews with witnesses and detectives involved in the case, the show offers a compelling look at the challenges faced by law enforcement when trying to solve cold cases. And as the story unfolds, viewers will be on the edge of their seat, waiting to see if justice will finally be served.

Overall, Cold Case Files season 4 episode 24, Rear Window / The Peeper, is a must-watch for fans of true crime shows and anyone who is interested in seeing how detectives work to crack difficult cases. With a compelling storyline and a cast of characters who are both complex and interesting, this episode is sure to keep viewers engaged from beginning to end.