The People's Court Season 22 Episode 35 "Your Dog Bit My Grandson in the Ear!"
- October 29, 2018
In this episode of The People's Court, the dispute centers around a dog bite. The plaintiff claims that the defendant's dog bit her grandson in the ear while they were visiting the defendant's home. The plaintiff alleges that the defendant was negligent in controlling her dog and did not take proper precautions to ensure the safety of her guests.
The defendant, on the other hand, claims that the plaintiff's grandson provoked her dog and that the dog acted in self-defense. She argues that she did everything she could to keep her dog under control and that the plaintiff's grandson should have known better than to approach the dog in a threatening manner.
The judge must determine who is responsible for the injury sustained by the plaintiff's grandson and whether the defendant should be held liable for any damages. To make this determination, the judge hears from witnesses on both sides and reviews any relevant evidence, including medical records and photos of the injury.
As the case unfolds, it becomes evident that there are several factors at play. For example, the judge must consider the behavior of both the dog and the plaintiff's grandson leading up to the bite, as well as any previous incidents involving the dog. In addition, the judge must weigh the evidence presented by both sides to determine what, if any, damages are appropriate.
Throughout the episode, tensions run high as both the plaintiff and defendant make impassioned arguments in front of the judge. At times, tempers flare and the judge must intervene to keep the proceedings on track. Despite the contentious nature of the case, the judge maintains a calm and measured demeanor, carefully considering all of the evidence before rendering a verdict.
In the end, the judge issues a ruling that takes into account all of the evidence presented. While neither party walks away completely satisfied, the judge's decision provides a measure of closure for both the plaintiff and defendant. Through it all, The People's Court provides a compelling look at our legal system and the complexities of settling disputes between individuals.